Best 5 Bagel 2 & 4 Slice Toaster You Can Buy In 2022 Reviews

If you like toasting your bagels, read my article.

I will present the 5 best toaster models that are suitable for toasting bagels. Read about their specifications and see which one would be the right option for you.

What To Know Before Buying A Bagel Toaster?

The Difference Between Conventional And Bagel Toasters

Bagel toasters have slots wide enough to fit bagels. The slots are usually 1.5-inches wide. Bagel toasters also have a bagel feature that toasts only the cut side of the bagel. The heating elements on the sides do not heat up so the outside of the bagel stays soft and warm.

Which Toaster Size To Choose?

If you need to toast larger quantities of bread or bagels, then I recommend buying a 4-slice or even commercial toaster model. If you do not toast a lot of bread or have a smaller kitchen, then opt for compact 2-slice models.

Useful Additional Features

Except for the bagel option, you can search for toasters with reheat or defrost options. Some toasters also have an LCD, a timer, a feature that memorizes your favorite settings, a feature that keeps your toast in the slots to preserve heat, etc. Depending on your wishes, choose the toaster with or without these features.

The Price Of Best Toaster For Bagels

Depending on the brand and quality, the price of bagel toasters ranges from around 20 dollars up to 200 dollars. More expensive models usually have sturdier constructions and guarantee long lifespan, but even the cheaper models offer high-quality products.

Where To Buy Bagel Toasters?

Online retailers, such as Amazon, have a wide range of bagel toasters from different brands. You can compare similar models and read customer reviews before buying your toaster. If you use their coupons and discounts, you can get a better deal on your bagel toaster.

Best 5 Bagel Toasters Reviews

Best Commercial Bagel Toaster

Waring Commercial WCT850RC Heavy Duty Toaster

Toast Large Quantities Of Bread

The Waring industrial bagel toaster can toast up to 360 slices per hour. This means that you can use it in professional kitchens as well. The toaster has four 1.5-inches wide slots where you can fit bagels or conventional toast.

Bagel And Bread Toaster Function

This toaster has a bagel/bread selector switch that you can use to choose the preferred toasting option. If you choose the bagel, the appliance toasts only one side of your bagel. You can also select the desired browning level of your toast by turning the corresponding knobs.

Dual Control Panels

The Waring 4-slice bagel toaster has two independent control panels. This means that you can select different settings for each pair of slots. This is convenient for busy kitchens because you can prepare different bread styles at the same time.

Compact And Easy To Clean

The Waring WCT850RC is 11.9 inches wide, 9 inches high and 10.5 inches deep. It does not take too much space in professional kitchens and can be placed on any countertop. It weighs 17.5 pounds. The toaster has a removable crumb tray that can be washed in the dishwasher.

Best 2-Slice Bagel Toaster

Black And Decker 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Extra-Wide Self-Adjusting Slots

This Black and Decker bagel toaster has 2 extra-wide slots so you can fit regular-sized bread or thick bagels, waffles and other pastries. The slots are self-adjusting, which means that they automatically adjust to the thickness of the bread you put in. This ensures even toasting results.

Features That You Can Use

The Black and Decker toaster has a bagel function that toasts the bagel on the cut side, while the outside gets warm. You can also use the frozen feature for defrosting the frozen toast. In case you want to stop the toasting cycle, there is a cancel option. These settings are selected by pressing the corresponding buttons.

More Useful Features

With this Black and Decker toaster, you can select 6 different shades of browning on the browning adjustment knob. It has a drop-down crumb tray for a fast clean-up. The base of the toaster can accommodate cord so it does not get tangled up while storing.

Space-Saving Dimensions

The toaster is approximately 13 inches long, 9.1 inches high and 8.4 inches wide. It has the power of 850 watts so the toast is done quickly. The toaster is available in two colors – black or white.

Best 4-Slice Bagel Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice toaster

Features Four Extra-Wide Slots

The Cuisinart CPT-180 has four slots where you can accommodate both thick and thin slices of bread and bagels. The bagel feature on this toaster toasts only the cut side of the bagel and leaves the outside soft and warm. If you want to toast both sides of the bagel, you do not have to press the bagel button.

Other Features And Options

Besides the bagel feature, this toaster has the defrost, reheat and cancel options. These features are selected by pressing the buttons with LED indicators. You can adjust the shade of the toast according to 6 different levels, from light to dark. There is a high-lift lever that you can use to retrieve smaller pastries.

Two-In-One Toaster

This Cuisinart 4-slice bagel toaster has dual independent control panels. This allows you to choose different settings for each pair of slots. This is convenient because you can prepare different bread styles at the same time and cater to different preferences of your family members.

Easy To Use And Clean

The control panel on this toaster is user-friendly. The toaster features a sliding crumb tray that makes the cleaning fast and simple. The housing is made from the stainless steel that is resistant to fingerprints. The base of the toaster features a cord wrap for easy storage.

Dimensions And Design

The dimensions of this Cuisinart bagel toaster are 11.15  x 10.65 x 7.5 inches. It is 1800 watts in power. It has a brushed stainless steel housing and black accents in the form of control knobs. The appliance is sturdy and durable. All plastic parts are BPA-free.

Best Long Slot Bagel Toaster

Breville BTA830XL Smart Toaster

Features A Motor Instead Of The Lever

This Breville bagel toaster has a motor that automatically lowers and lifts the bread you put in the slots. You just need to press the control buttons on the top of the toaster. The slots are wide enough to accommodate bagels and other types of bread. The toaster features 2 long slots so you can fit up to 4 slices of toast or longer breads.

Other Useful Features

The Breville BTA830XL has a bagel feature, defrost, ‘a bit more’ and ‘lift and look’ feature. A bit more adds an extra 30 seconds to the toasting cycle if you want a crispier toast. Lift and look automatically lifts the toast so you can check the progress, but it does not stop the toasting cycle. These are selected by pressing the backlit control buttons.

Features An LED Panel

This long-slot bagel toaster has an LED panel that shows the toasting time left so you can control the progress of your toast. When the toast is done, the sound goes off. You can adjust how loud you want your signal to be or you can shut it off completely.

Suitable For Smaller Countertops

This Breville toaster is long so it takes less horizontal space. The dimensions of the toaster are 14.9 by 7.7 by 7.5 inches and it weighs 8.25 pounds so it will not slide on your counter. It has a brushed die-cast metal housing. For more convenience, there is a sliding crumb tray and cord storage at the base of the toaster.

Best Mini Bagel Toaster

Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster 22633

Toast Different Bread Styles

This toaster has 2 extra-wide slots so you can fit bagels or other toasting pastries such as regular-sized toast, English muffins, waffles, etc. You can use the bagel option to toast only the cut side of the bagel and defrost to thaw the bread prior to toasting for crispier results.

Adjust The Shade Of Your Toast

You can use the shade control knob at the front of the toaster to choose the desired shade of toast, from light to dark. The control buttons for the bagel, defrost and cancel features are backlit so you get the overview of the chosen setting.

Easily Retrieve The Toast

The Hamilton Beach bagel toaster pops the toast out once it is done. If you toast smaller pastries, you can use the high-lift lever to get easier access to the toast. In case the toast gets jammed, the toaster shuts off automatically. The toaster also features a removable crumb tray.

Space-Saving Dimensions For Small Kitchens

This Hamilton Beach toaster is 11.3 inches deep, 7.5 inches wide and 7.5 inches tall. It weighs only 2.75 pounds. The outside of the toaster remains cool to the touch. The toaster is black and has brushed stainless steel elements.

Conclusion: What Is The Best Toaster For Bagels?

If you ask me, the best bagel toasters would be the Breville BTA830XL Smart Toaster and the Hamilton Beach 22633 2-Slice Toaster. The Breville bagel toaster has a motor for lowering and lifting the bread and is suitable for longer bread as well. The Hamilton Beach toaster is compact and cheap and has the bagel and defrost functions.

If you would like to read more about other toasters, follow my best toasters on sale article. Also, make sure to check out the best 2-slice toasters. If you need a toaster for your restaurant or coffee shop, read about the best commercial bread toasters.